Live Chat

Addition of Amazon to Dow Jones index fails to address “relevance” problem

Dow Jones index update still leaves it with a relevance problem, say analysts

The inclusion of e-commerce giant Amazon.com into the Dow Jones Industrial Average, a U.S. stock benchmark with a history extending over 125 years, has not fully addressed the index’s “relevance” problem, as per analysts at Ned Davis Research recently cited by MarketWatch.

The swap, which saw Amazon replace Walgreens Boots Alliance Inc. in the 30-stock index in late February, gave the Dow more exposure to the large technology companies that have been pivotal in driving U.S. stock markets to new heights.

However, experts like Ed Clissold, chief U.S. strategist at Ned Davis, and London Stockton, a research strategist at the firm, suggest that the Dow should incorporate more leading technology firms — “tech titans” — to maintain its relevance as a stock market barometer.

Choose your points of movement

Сalculate your hypothetical P/L (aggregated cost and charges) if you had opened a trade today.

Market

Currency Search
Currency
Index
Shares
ETFs
Bonds
Crypto
Commodity

Instrument

Search
Clear input
Occidental
Siemens
Morgan Stanley
GSX Techedu
Marston's
Alibaba
Skillz Inc
Macy's
Lemonade
Lululemon
Plug Power
Amazon.com
Verizon
Thermo Fisher
Mondelez
General Motors
LVMH
IAG
Cinemark
PETROCHINA
Royal Bank Canada
Anglo American
F5 Networks
Nikola Corporation
Zoom Video Communications
Air France-KLM
Comcast
UniCredit
The Cheesecake Factory
Barrick Gold
Bayer
Toro
Kuaishou
Gen Digital Inc
Tilray
Xiaomi
SMCI
Wish.com Inc
Adobe
DISNEY
Coinbase Inc
UiPath Inc
T-Mobile
Rio Tinto
Schlumberger
Invesco Mortgage
Hammerson
Volkswagen
Sartorius AG
ROBLOX Corp
ChargePoint Holdings Inc
UPS
Pinterest Inc
Continental
Jumia Technologies
Medtronic
PayPal
Twilio
Freeport McMoRan
UnitedHealth
SIG
Tesla
Lyft
Boeing Co
Annaly Capital
Santander
Teladoc
Li Auto
CrowdStrike Holdings
Deere
Fedex
Naspers
ProSiebenSat.1
Bilibili Inc
Costco
New Oriental
NVIDIA
Iberdrola
Gilead
American Express
Apple
Airbus
GoPro
Chevron
HSBC HK
Two Harbors Investment aration
easyJet
Inditex
BlackBerry
Anheuser-Busch Inbev
Deliveroo Holdings
Hubspot
Applied Materials
GameStop
British American Tobacco
Trade Desk
McDonald's
AMC Entertainment Holdings
Adidas
AIA
Bristol Myers
Novavax
TUI
Fresnillo
Shell plc (LSE)
Nasdaq
Ceconomy
Lithium Americas Corp
Rivian Automotive
Qorvo
MercadoLibre.com
Coca-Cola Co (NYSE)
HDFC Bank
Roku Inc
Infinera
Arista
Total
JnJ
Dave & Buster's
PG&E
ON Semiconductor
Diageo
XPeng Inc
ASML
Vodafone
Airbus Group SE
Campari
Telecom Italia
Glencore plc
HSBC
ZIM Integrated Shipping Services Ltd
Kraft Heinz
Spotify
Aurora Cannabis Inc
Etsy
Goldman Sachs
Norwegian Air Shuttle
Abbott
Snap
Linde PLC
Blackstone
Cellnex
Tencent
Barclays
Virgin Galactic
JP Morgan
Allianz
RTX Corp
Taiwan Semi
Wal-Mart Stores
Intel
DoorDash
Wayfair
SONY
II-VI
Norwegian Cruise Line
BioNTech
Palantir Technologies Inc
CNOOC
Cisco Systems
Electrolux
ALIBABA HK
Robinhood
Vonovia
British American Tobacco
SAP
Ford
Cameco
Peloton Interactive Inc.
Toyota
Amgen
AT&T
Infosys
Starbucks
Lloyds
Qualcomm
Canopy Growth
3D Systems
CarMax
LUCID
Eni
AMD
Target
IBM
FirstRand
Lumentum Holdings
Alphabet (Google)
Workday Inc
ASOS
Conoco Phillips
Moderna Inc
Trump Media & Technology Group
Fuelcell
MerckCo USA
Salesforce.com
Hermes
BASF
AstraZeneca
Christian Dior
Broadcom
Oracle
Vipshop
CCB (Asia)
Nio
Block
Uber
Accenture
Meta (Formerly Facebook)
Berkshire Hathaway
Wells Fargo
Blackrock
Rolls-Royce
Pfizer
Microsoft
Home Depot
Mastercard
Lufthansa
Marriott
AbbVie
China Life
Baidu
Eli Lilly
DeltaAir
Chipotle
BP
General Electric
eBay
Quanta Services
Netflix
Micron
Visa
Golar LNG
ADT
JD.com
American Airlines
Porsche AG
Palo Alto Networks
Teleperformance
Lockheed Martin
Upstart Holdings Inc
Delivery Hero SE
Airbnb Inc
Nel ASA
GoHealth
Shopify
Aptiv PLC
Bank of America
PepsiCo
Philip Morris
Exxon Mobil
Procter & Gamble
Beyond Meat
Snowflake
L'Oreal
Sea
Porsche
Deutsche Bank
Nike
Unilever
CAT
Prosus N.V.
Unity Software
Citigroup
Upwork Inc.
Vir Biotechnology

Account Type

Direction

Quantity

Amount must be equal or higher than

Amount should be less than

Amount should be a multiple of the minimum lots increment

USD Down
$-

Value

$-

Commission

$-

Spread

-

Leverage

-

Conversion Fee

$-

Required Margin

$-

Overnight Swaps

$-
Start Trading

Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.

All positions on instruments denominated in a currency that is different from your account currency, will be subject to a conversion fee at the position exit as well.

How does the Dow Jones index work?

Despite Amazon's addition to the index, the Dow continues to be heavily invested in sectors such as finance, healthcare, and consumer discretionary, leaving it lagging in technology representation compared to the S&P 500.

“The DJIA has trailed the S&P 500 by 6.9% over the last 12 months, which puts it in the bottom 10% of trailing 12 months relative returns,” the Ned Davis team wrote in client note on February 26.

The Dow calculates stock impacts not on market capitalization — the total value of all the shares on the index — but through a "divisor." The divisor is a number that a Dow component’s price change is divided by to determine what effect that stock’s move has on the index.

Complicating matters further, Amazon is also classified as a consumer discretionary stock, even though investors often include in the “Magnificent Seven” — a group of megacap top tech stocks that have helped propel the S&P 500 index above the 5,000 mark to a series of record highs this year.

The Dow already includes prominent tech companies like Apple Inc., Microsoft Corp., and Salesforce Inc., yet it lacks other key players such as Alphabet Inc., the parent company of Google, and chipmaker Nvidia, which is on the forefront of the AI boom. The researchers from Ned Davis argue that adding more significant tech names would make the Dow more appealing to investors.

On the day of the announcement, stock markets saw a slight downturn, with the Dow dropping 0.2%, the S&P 500 falling 0.3%, and the Nasdaq Composite seeing a minor decline of less than 0.1%.

At the time of writing on Monday, March 4, Amazon shares were up 17.3% year-to-date (YTD), and 90.1% up on a 12-month basis — compared to the DJIA’s respective 3.71% (YTD) and 17.06% (1-year). The S&P 500 index has seen growth of 7.7% YTD and 26.98% over the past year, last closing at 5,127.08 on March 1.

When considering shares and indices for trading and price predictions, remember that trading CFDs involves a significant degree of risk and could result in capital loss.

Past performance is not indicative of any future results. This information is provided for informative purposes only and should not be construed to be investment advice.

Latest news

New Zealand dollar drops on unexpected dovish tone from RBNZ

Wednesday, 10 July 2024

Indices

Unexpected dovish tone from RBNZ drops New Zealand dollar

Sterling steady as investors take in UK, French election results

Tuesday, 9 July 2024

Indices

Sterling steady near one-month high in wake of UK election

BP shares fall on Q2 profit warning

Tuesday, 9 July 2024

Indices

BP shares drop over 4% on Q2 lower profit warning

BP shares dip ahead of Powell Congress testimony

Tuesday, 9 July 2024

Indices

BP dips, Powell Congress speech ahead, records for Tokyo, NY

Live Chat